Orthopaedic Second Opinion
A Clearer Understanding Before You Decide on Treatment
Have you been advised to undergo knee replacement, ligament surgery, hip replacement, or another major orthopaedic procedure? If you are unsure about your diagnosis or treatment plan, Dr. Amyn Rajani provides an independent orthopaedic second opinion based on a detailed review of your medical history, imaging, clinical findings, and proposed treatment, helping patients in Mumbai and beyond understand their condition and options before deciding.
- 20+ Years of Clinical Experience
- M.S. Orth (Gold Medallist)
- 100+ Research Citations
Call +91 22 2369 6161

Before You Say Yes to Surgery, Understand Why It Has Been Recommended
A major orthopaedic decision can involve surgery, rehabilitation, recovery time and significant financial considerations. A second opinion gives you an opportunity to have your diagnosis and proposed treatment independently reviewed.
It can be particularly useful when:
- You have been advised to undergo knee or hip replacement.
- Different doctors have given you different opinions.
- Your pain has continued despite treatment.
- Surgery has been presented as the only option.
- You have been diagnosed with a complex or uncommon condition.
- You are considering changing surgeons or hospitals.
- You want greater clarity before proceeding with an elective procedure.

What Does Dr. Rajani Review?
A second opinion goes beyond reviewing an MRI report. Dr. Rajani considers your medical history, previous investigations, clinical findings and proposed treatment together to understand whether the recommended approach is appropriate for your condition.
Previous Medical Reports:
X-rays, MRI scans, CT scans, blood reports, previous operative notes and your existing treatment plan.
Clinical Examination:
Joint movement, tenderness, ligament stability, swelling or effusion, gait mechanics and neurovascular status during an in-person consultation.
Proposed Treatment:
The reason for the recommended procedure, whether surgery is appropriate, whether conservative treatment may be considered, whether a less invasive option exists, whether further investigation is needed and what recovery may involve.
Clinical and Imaging Correlation:
Whether the findings seen on your scans correspond with your symptoms and physical examination.
The OAKS Second Opinion Process
A structured five-step process helps Dr. Rajani review your medical information, assess your condition and provide a clear, independent treatment opinion.
01. Share Your Medical Records
Share your MRI scans, X-rays, previous operative notes and current treatment plan so Dr. Rajani can review your medical history before the consultation.
02. Clinical Examination
Dr. Rajani performs an independent examination to assess joint movement, tenderness, stability and other clinical findings that may not appear on imaging alone.
03. Review Your Treatment
You and Dr. Rajani review your diagnosis and proposed treatment to confirm the recommendation is appropriate and to consider other options.
04. Discuss Your Options
Depending on your condition, Dr. Rajani discusses relevant non-surgical, minimally invasive, joint preservation or surgical options to support informed treatment decisions.
05. Receive a Written Summary
After the consultation, OAKS Clinic provides a written summary of Dr. Rajani's findings and recommendations that you can share with your existing medical team.
Which Orthopaedic Conditions Can Be Reviewed?
Dr. Rajani provides second opinions across knee, shoulder and hip conditions, with relevant treatment and procedure pages available for patients who want to understand each condition in greater detail.
Knee Conditions

- Knee Osteoarthritis – Review of diagnosis, treatment options and joint replacement recommendations.
- Total Knee Replacement – Independent review of whether knee replacement is appropriate.
- Partial Knee Replacement – Assessment of suitability for partial joint replacement.
- Knee Cartilage Damage – Review of cartilage injuries and available treatment options.
- Osteochondral Defects – Assessment of cartilage and underlying bone damage.
- Knee Avascular Necrosis – Review of diagnosis and treatment options.

Ligament and Meniscus Injuries
- ACL Tear and Reconstruction – Review of ACL injury, reconstruction recommendations and treatment options.
- PCL Tear – Assessment of posterior cruciate ligament injuries and treatment.
- Multiligament Knee Injuries – Specialist review of complex ligament injuries.
- Meniscus Tear – Assessment of meniscal injuries and treatment options.
Patellar and MPFL Conditions
- Patellar Dislocation – Review of recurrent or first-time kneecap dislocation.
- Patellar Instability – Assessment of kneecap movement and underlying causes.
- MPFL Tear and Reconstruction – Review of MPFL injury and reconstruction recommendations.
- Trochlear Dysplasia – Assessment of abnormal trochlear anatomy associated with instability.
- Patella Alta – Review of high-riding patella and its role in knee instability.
Shoulder Conditions
- Rotator Cuff Tear – Review of diagnosis and treatment recommendations.
- Shoulder Impingement – Assessment of symptoms, imaging and treatment options.
- Frozen Shoulder – Review of adhesive capsulitis and available treatment.
- Shoulder Arthritis – Assessment of joint degeneration and treatment options.
- SLAP Tear – Review of labral injury and recommended management.


Hip Conditions
- Hip Osteoarthritis – Review of diagnosis and treatment options.
- Total Hip Replacement – Independent assessment of hip replacement recommendations.
- Hip Avascular Necrosis – Review of diagnosis and joint preservation options.
- Femoroacetabular Impingement – Assessment of hip impingement and treatment options.
- Hip Labral Tear – Review of labral injury and appropriate management.
Joint Preservation and Complex Cases
- Osteotomy – Assessment of suitability for corrective bone surgery.
- Joint Preservation vs Replacement – Review of options for preserving the natural joint.
- Arthritis in Younger Patients – Assessment of treatment options beyond immediate joint replacement.
- Revision Joint Replacement – Independent review of persistent problems after joint replacement.

In-Person or Online Orthopaedic Second Opinion?
Whether you visit OAKS Clinic or consult Dr. Rajani online, both options provide a structured review of your diagnosis, medical records, imaging and proposed treatment. You can choose the format based on your location, availability and consultation needs.
| Consultation | In-Person | Online Consultation |
|---|---|---|
| Clinical assessment | Includes a detailed physical examination of the affected joint. | Includes a detailed discussion of your symptoms and medical history. |
| Medical records | We can review previous reports and original imaging during your visit. | We can share reports and digital imaging before the consultation. |
| Treatment review | We discuss diagnosis and treatment options after clinical assessment. | We review your diagnosis and proposed treatment based on your records and imaging. |
| Written opinion | A written summary of Dr. Rajani's findings is provided. | A written summary of Dr. Rajani's findings is also provided. |
| Ideal for | Patients who want a complete physical examination or have complex conditions. | Patients travelling from outside Mumbai or those who prefer the convenience of a remote consultation. |
| Consultation time | Approximately 30 to 60 minutes. | Approximately 20 to 40 minutes. |
Prefer to Consult From Home?
Patients from other cities and countries can start with an online orthopaedic second opinion by sharing their medical records and imaging in advance. If an in-person examination is later recommended, we can plan the visit accordingly.
About Dr. Amyn Rajani
Dr. Rajani combines specialist training, surgical experience, academic research and clinical expertise to provide an informed review of complex orthopaedic conditions.
International Course Faculty
Holds 5 international faculty appointments.
100+ Research Citations
Dr. Rajani's published research in peer-reviewed orthopaedic journals has been cited more than 100 times.
3,000+ Procedures, including knee reconstruction, joint replacement, and arthroscopy.
Google Scholar Profile
His publications and citations are listed on his Google Scholar profile.
Robotic Surgery Certified
He is certified on the MAKO, CORI and ROSA robotic surgery systems.
AMR Sign
Dr. Rajani developed the AMR Sign, an original clinical manoeuvre used to assess MPFL tears.
Record Recognition
His work has been recognised in the Limca Book of Records for performing the highest number of knee arthroscopy surgeries in a single day.
Need an Orthopaedic Second Opinion From Outside Mumbai?
If travelling to Mumbai is difficult, you can begin with an online orthopaedic second opinion from Dr. Amyn Rajani. Share your medical records and imaging in advance for a detailed review of your condition and proposed treatment. If a physical examination or surgery is later recommended, you can schedule an in-person consultation at OAKS Clinic.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q1. Will a second opinion offend my current doctor?
Seeking a second opinion before a major orthopaedic procedure is an accepted part of medical decision-making. It allows you to better understand the diagnosis and treatment options before proceeding.
Q2. Can I get a second opinion after surgery?
Yes. A postoperative second opinion can help assess persistent pain, delayed recovery, or the need for revision surgery.
Q3. Do I need to visit OAKS Clinic for a second opinion?
Not always. A remote consultation may suit some patients, particularly those travelling from outside Mumbai. An in-person consultation allows a physical examination and may be recommended for complex cases.
Q4. What documents should I bring?
Bring your previous X-rays, MRI scans, CT scans, blood reports, operative notes if applicable, and the treatment plan or recommendation provided by your current doctor.
Q5. Can Dr. Rajani review my proposed knee replacement?
Yes. A second opinion can include a review of a recommendation for total or partial knee replacement, including the diagnosis, imaging and available treatment options.
Q6. Can I get a second opinion for an ACL or MPFL injury?
Yes. Dr. Rajani provides second opinions for ACL injuries, PCL injuries, meniscus tears, MPFL tears, patellar instability and related knee conditions.
Q7. How long does the consultation take?
An in-person second opinion typically takes around 30 to 60 minutes. Remote consultations generally take around 20 to 40 minutes.
Q8. How soon can I get an appointment?
Appointments are typically available within 3 to 5 working days, with urgent cases such as suspected infection or failed implants prioritised for earlier review.


